The Nepal Digest - Oct 6, 1994 (1 Kartik 2051 BkSm)

From: The Editor (
Date: Thu Oct 06 1994 - 08:30:48 CDT

Received: from ( []) by (8.6.9/8.6.9) with SMTP id MAA14224 for <>; Thu, 6 Oct 1994 12:23:26 -0500
Received: by id AA09947 (5.67b/IDA-1.5 for nepal-dist); Thu, 6 Oct 1994 08:30:50 -0500
Received: by id AA09943 (5.67b/IDA-1.5 for nepal-list); Thu, 6 Oct 1994 08:30:48 -0500
Date: Thu, 6 Oct 1994 08:30:48 -0500
Message-Id: <>
Reply-To: The Nepal Digest <>
From: The Editor <>
Sender: "Rajpal J. Singh" <>

Subject:      The Nepal Digest - Oct 6, 1994 (1 Kartik 2051 BkSm)
To: <>
Content-Type: text
Content-Length: 41176
Status: O
X-UID: 37

        % N N EEEEEE PPPPPP AA L %
        % NN N E P P A A L %
        % N N N EEEE P P A A L %
        % N N N E PPPPPP AAAAAA L %
        % N NN E P A A L %
        % N N EEEEEE P A A LLLLLL %

The Nepal Digest Thursday 6 Oct 94: Kartik 1 2051 BkSm Volume 32 Issue 1

  * TND Board of Staff *
  * ------------------ *
  * Editor/Co-ordinator: Rajpal J. Singh *
  * SCN Correspondent: Rajesh B. Shrestha *
  * Editing Editor: Padam P. Sharma *
  * Discussion Moderator: Rajendra P. Shrestha*
  * *
  * Subscription/Deletion requests : NEPAL-REQUEST@CS.NIU.EDU *
  * Provide one line message: sub nepal "lastname, firstname, mi" <user@host> *
  * [OPTIONAL] Provide few lines about your occupation, address, phone for *
  * TND database to: <A10RJS1@CS.NIU.EDU> *
  * Snail-Mail Correspondences to: Rajpal J. Singh *
  * Founding-editor/Co-ordinator *
  * The Nepal Digest (TND) *
  * 502 West Lincoln Highway *
  * DeKalb, Illinois 60115, U.S.A. *
  * Digest Contributions: NEPAL@CS.NIU.EDU *
  * Discussion Topics ideas: RAJENDRA.SHRESTHA@DARTMOUTH.EDU *
  * News clips for Taja_Khabar: RANA@CCIT.ARIZONA.EDU *
  * Contributors need to supply Header for the article, email, and full name. *
  * *
  * Postings are divided into following categories that are listed in the *
  * order below. Please provide category-type in the header of your e-mail. *
  * *
  * 1. Message from TND Editorial Board *
  * 2. Letter to the Editor *
  * 3. TAJA_KHABAR: Current News *
  * 4. KATHA_KABITA: Literature *
  * 5. KURA_KANI: Economics *
  * Agriculture *
  * Forestry *
  * Health *
  * Education *
  * Technology *
  * Social Issues *
  * Environment *
  * Tourism *
  * Foreign Policy *
  * History *
  * Military/Police *
  * Politics *
  * 6. Entertainment (Humor, Recipies, Movie Reviews, Sattaires etc.) *
  * 7. JAN_KARI: Classifieds *
  * 8. Immigration/Taxes *
  * 9. TITAR_BITAR: Miscellaneous *
  * *
  * The Nepal Digest(TND) is a publication of the Nepal Interest Group for *
  * news and discussions about issues concerning Nepal. All members of *
  * will get a copy of TND. Membership is open to all. *
  * *
  * **** COPYRIGHT NOTE **** *
  * The news/article posters are responsible for any copyright violations. *
  * TND, a non-profit electronic journal, will publish articles that has *
  * been published in other electronic or paper journal with proper credit *
  * to the original media. *
  * *
  * +++++ Food For Thought +++++ *
  * "If you don't stand up for something, you will fall for anything" - Anon. *
  * "Democracy perishes among the silent crowd" - Sirdar_RJS_Khalifa *
  * *
************************************************************* Date: Mon, 19 Sep 1994 17:35:22 -0400 (EDT) From: Ashutosh Tiwari <> Subject: Great to be back!! To: Nepal Digest <>

It's great to be back in cyberspace, and into the familiar fold of TND.

Kudos to all of you for running TND so well and actively. All of you guys derseve a top-most "Gorkha Dakshin Bahu" for all that you've been doing to bring Nepalis (and friends of Nepal) in front of the screen to talk about that certain special place between China and India.

Scanning the back issues, I read the debates/kura-kanis on Arun III and
"why so many SLC failures" with interest.

Though I question the logic and the economics behind the Arun III project on PROCEDURAL grounds (more on this when and if I have time!), I fully DISagree with Amulya's 'justification' for the high number of failures on the SLC (i.e. "there's no seat at the college" argument; and, "it's all politicians' fault" analysis). Well, more on this later, too.

Meantime, Bhupendra Pradhan, where are you? Not at HMS; that much, I've found out.

namaste ashu

********************************************************* Date: Tue, 20 Sep 1994 15:03:02 EDT From: pramod@UFCC.UFL.EDU To: Subject: expressing appreciation

i should like to thank all the nepalese students and vaujus at the university of florida,gainesville for helping me survive first few days of nostalgia.i do not intend this to sound emotional but i have no faith in time,let not the time recite,it may have a different version,and sometimes so called "hipocrisy"rules me and it does argue so wrongly about my identity,i am not judge of my conscience then. pramod dhakal,uf.

**************************************************************** Date: 22 Sep 94 10:22:05 EDT From: Rajendra.P.Shrestha@Dartmouth.EDU (Rajendra P. Shrestha) Subject: News9/21 To:

SOURCE: AFP HEADLINE: Rights groups invite observers to monitor Nepal's polls DATELINE: KATHMANDU, Sept 20

   Six human rights groups here plan to invite 100 international observers from about 40 different countries to monitor Nepal's forthcoming mid-term polls, a spokesman of one of the groups said Tuesday.

   The polls are being held in November to elect 205 members of the House of Representatives to five-year terms.

   The six groups have formed a National Election Observation Committee (NEOC) to ensure the vote is held in a "free, fair and impartial manner", a NEOC spokesman said.

   The NEOC has decided that pre-election preparations must be speeded up, and is asking for the cooperation of political parties, government agencies, the election commission and the police, the spokesman said.

   The date of the poll, originally scheduled for November 11, will be announced within a couple of weeks. King Birendra has asked the Supreme Court whether the timing can be altered.

   The House of Representatives was dissolved on July 11 by the king on the advice of the premier after his government lost a crucial parliamentary debate in July.

   Following his defeat in parliament, the premier resigned, but the king appointed him to head the caretaker government and to oversee the polls.
--------------------------------------------------------------------- SOURCE: AFP HEADLINE: Nepalese king gets presidential welcome in France DATELINE: PARIS, Sept 20

    Nepal's King Birendra on Tuesday began a four-day state visit to France marking his first official trip to Europe since saving his monarchy by accepting greater democracy in 1990.

   The visit, during which he will hold talks with President Francois Mitterrand and Prime Minister Edouard Balladur, is aimed at boosting political and economic links between the two countries.

   Accompanied by Queen Aishwarya, the king was welcomed at Paris' Orly airport by Mitterrand, with whom he was due to hold talks later in the day at the Elysee presidential palace, ahead of a reception in the evening.

   To the sound of the French and Nepalese national anthems, the two men passed in review troops from air, sea and land forces, before leaving the airport by helicopter for central Paris.

   The trip, the first by a Nepalese head of state to France, follows up on an invitation extended by Mitterrand during a trip to the Himalayan mountain kingdom in 1983.

   "The visit will not only deepen our bilateral ties but further strengthen it to the mutual benefit of Nepal and France. It will open a golden chapter in France- Nepal relations," said Kathmandu's ambassador here, H.E. Keshav Raf Jha.

   A spokesman for the French foreign ministry said the trip was aimed at "developing relations with a country resolutely committed to respecting democracy and human rights."

   Talks with the French president Tuesday evening will be followed by discussions Wednesday with Paris mayor Jacques Chirac, Foreign Minister Alain Juppe and National Assembly speaker Philippe Seguin.

   The royal visitor is due to meet Balladur for talks Thursday.

   Later that day he will travel on France's high-speed TGV train for a tour of one of France's most famous wine-producing regions -- the Burgundy region south, where he will stay Friday.

   The king, also accompanied by Princess Shruti and Ram Hari Joshi, Nepal's minister of tourism and aviation, is due to leave France Monday afternoon, returning via Italy and the United Arab Emirates.

   Birendra stressed the importance of the visit before he left Kathmandu. "French support and cooperation have positively helped redress these constraints," he said in an interview with AFP.

   "I hope visits su ch as the present one will contribute to further consolidating our ties."

   In 1991, France cancelled Nepal's debts to Paris of around 17.5 million dollars and added a grant of 50 million francs (8.75 million dollars).

   France is also helping with work to preserve Nepal's historic monuments and gave six million francs (one million dollars) in food aid in 1994.

   Birendra, in one of the most critical periods in Nepalese history, agreed in 1990 to give up his absolute power and allow a multi-party system in his mountain homeland.

   His trip to France comes at time of new troubles, with Prime Minister Girija Prasad Koirala forced to call new elections for November after being put in a minority in parliament.

   It will not be Birendra's first visit to France. He first travelled here while a student at Eton in England in 1963, but has visited twice since then.

SOURCE: International Herald Tribune HEADLINE: Tapping Into Nepal's Hydropower Potential BYLINE: Jon Liden DATELINE: KATMANDU

    How can the fourth poorest country in the world raise the equivalent of severtimes its own GDP to develop its water resources? That is the question
 Nepal is pondering, while billions of potential kilowatt-HL hours are running into the sea.

    Nepal has one of the world's largest potentials for hydropower development, yeonly 10 percent of the country's population has access to electricity, and the capital, Katmandu, has regular brown- outs. Hydropower, which is considered the cleanest of the world's main energy sources, is also one of the cheapest in production. But the capital expenses of building access roads, dams and turbine stations are staggeringly high for a poor country. In Nepal only 241 megawatts of an exploitable capacity of at least 35,000 megawatts has been developed.

   However, Nepal may see a dramatic increase in its power- generating capacity over the next decade. By using a combination of domestic economic reform, aid-sponsored credit arrangements and the private sector's increased willingnessand capability to engage in infrastructure projects, Nepal is working out a formula to increase its power production drastically without taking on huge new debts.

   "Our government is committed to develop hydropower both from the private sectoand from the public sector," said Nepal's minister for water resources, Laxman Ghimire.

   The government, Nepal's first democratically elected one since 1959, has cut subsidies of electricity and slimmed the Nepal Electricity Authority by 1,200 people to conform with World Bank demands.

    Nepal has also passed two laws and a hydropower development policy, which giveforeign and domestic private investors 20-30 year licenses to develop and operate hydroHL power projects. The regulations give more favorable concessions on income tax and import duty than the ordinary foreign investment regulations, creating one of Asia's most generous legal investment environments.

   Two projects are currently putting the new regulations to the test.

   In July, Snowy Mountain Engineering Corp. of Australia signed a memorandum of understanding with the Nepali government to develop the
$600 million, 360 megawatt West Seti dam project over a 30-year period. The plan is to export 90 percent of the power to India. "We have been looking at West Seti for two years,and feel that this was the right time to move," said Damien Keneally, general manager for hydropower at the Australian company. "The climate is right for commercial development of hydropower in Nepal, and there are large shortages of power in India."

   The project could be in place by 2000 if the technical study and negotiations with India for sales of power live up to Snowy Mountain's expectations. Feasibility studies have shown that an 18 percent rate of return on investment would be possible for sales from West Seti to India, provided India carries out an expected reform of its energy-pricing system, which currently is based on large subsidies.

   The International Finance Corp., the World Bank's private-sector arm, and the Asian Development Bank, are discussing becoming involved. Since this project is among the first of its kind, commercial banks are less reluctant to commit moneyif the international credit institutions are involved, analysts say.

   A second project is the $120 million, 60 megawatt Khimti Kola, which is developed by a joint venture between a Nepali hydropower company and three Norwegian companies; Statkraft, Kvaerner Energy and ABB Energy, an affiliate of Asea Brown Boveri. This project is fully financed by export credits and soft loans from Norway, the IFC and ADB, and construction has already started.

   Still, no matter how many projects are started over the next few years, Nepal will face serious energy shortages until at least 2002. The reason, oddly enough, is the country's main hydropower project, the Arun III.

   First planned in 1985, the $770 million, 201 megawatt Arun III project has beea marathon process: after nine years, the World Bank and other main donors have not yet firmly committed to financing it.

   Some say it is a typical example of how international aid efforts can slow dowand increase the cost of infrastructure projects. A Nepali pressure group, the Alliance for Energy, accuses the donors and the government of being too concerned with putting the dam in place, and showing too little concern with theeconomic viability of the project.

   "World Bank staff's main concern is to make sure there are no cost overruns anlong delays in the construction phase. That means large safety margins that drive the budgets up," argued Bikash Pandey, an engineer and one of the leading critics of the Arun III project. "A private license holder, on the other hand, would make sure that costs are as low as possible to ensure a reasonable rate ofreturn on investment."

   The fact that $325 million in grants from Japan and Germany are tied to purchases of equipment from these two countries adds to the expenses, Mr. Pandeyclaims. "Tied aid purchases have been shown to be up to 30 percent more expensive than purchases based on international bidding," he said.

   This is the main reason why Arun III is nearly double the cost per kilowatt compared with West Seti, according to the Alliance for Energy. The group questions calculations by the government and the World Bank that show electricity from Arun III costing around 5.9 U.S. cents per kilowatt-hour.

"Our calculations point towards a real price of 12 cents," Mr. Pandey said.

   As important is the criticism that Nepal has frozen the development of any major new power project while Arun III is under consideration. "Since the Arun III project has been delayed and delayed again, Nepal has slid into a serious gap between energy supply and consumption needs which will cost us dearly until Arun is finally on tap in year 2002," said a senior official at the Nepal Electricity Authority, who could not be named. "It is absurd that we need to usediesel- driven power plants to cover our shortages. Thermal energy in Nepal is as sick as hydropower in Kuwait," he said.

   The long planning stage of Arun III is due to a series of studies ranging fromthe loan burden's effect on other sectors of the economy to the project's threatto a rare butterfly species in the Arun river valley.

   The main donors, the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, are bent on making the Arun III a model project, technically, environmentally and socially. Yet European and American environmentalists have campaigned against the project.

   By most accounts, Arun III's negative environmental and social effects are minimal. "The locals are very much in favor of Arun III," said Barun Gurung, an anthropologist who works in the Arun valley.

   Now, most people In Nepal say that Arun III has to be developed, if for nothinelse, so at least to get it out of the way so other projects can get attention. A final decision from the World Bank is expected on the Arun III project by November.

   Meanwhile, the Nepali government is growing impatient with the project, and habeen approving others, notably Khimti Kola and West Seti. "The ball is entirely in the World Bank's court," said Mr. Ghimire, the minister for water resources.


*********************************************************************************************** Date: 23 Sep 94 14:16:31 EDT From: Rajendra.P.Shrestha@Dartmouth.EDU (Rajendra P. Shrestha) Subject: News9/21-22 To:

SOURCE: AFP HEADLINE: EU wants economic deal with Nepal: Juppe DATELINE: PARIS, Sept 21
   The European Union is anxious to negotiate a development aid agreement with
 Nepal, French Foreign Minister Alain Juppe told Nepal's King Birendra during talks here on Wednesday.

   French officials said talks on the agreement could begin when France takes over the EU presidency from Germany on January 1.

   King Birendra, on the second day of a four-day state visit to France, discussed United Nations peace-keeping missions with Juppe, the officials said.

   The Himalayan kingdom has provided some 900 peacekeepers for the UN force in former Yugoslavia.

   Birendra and Juppe also discussed developing international cooperation to fight drug-smuggling. Nepal is one of the transit points for opium from south Asia's "golden triangle."

   On Tuesday, Birendra held talks with French President Francois Mitterrand, who hosted the monarch at a state dinner.

   Birendra is on the first visit to France by a Nepalese head of state, in response to an invitation extended by Mitterrand during a trip to Kathmandu in 1983.

   The king is due to meet Prime Minister Edouard Balladur for talks Thursday.

   Later that day he will travel on France's high-speed TGV train for a tour of one of the country's most famous wine-producing regions -- the Burgundy region, where he will stay Friday.

   The king, also accompanied by Princess Shruti and Ram Hari Joshi, Nepal's minister of tourism and aviation, is due to leave France Monday afternoon, returning via Italy and the United Arab Emirates.

SOURCE: Xinhua HEADLINE: nepali congress leader's quitting regretted DATELINE: kathmandu, september 21; ITEM NO: 0921079
   president of nepali congress (nc), the former ruling party, krishna prasad bhattarai deeply regretted over the sudden departure of ganesh man singh, one of the nc founders, from the party. "singh's absence is a blow to the nc's election prospects," bhattarai was quoted today by local english daily "the kathmandu post" as saying in what is believed to be the first comment from a nc leader on singh's quitting decision announced at a press conference on september 16. in an interview with the paper on tuesday, bhattarai complained that singh had even "failed to receive singh's blessings for the coming general elections" to be held on november 13. however, the nc president did not give any comment on the two conditions raised by singh. in his quitting statement, singh said, "if they want me to remain in the party, they should fulfill two conditions: firstly, the prime minister should resign; secondly, the president should reorganize all party branches." as to whether he would contest the polls, bhattarai said,
"i have already lost three elections. but if i decide to contest now i'm sure i'll win overwhelmingly." bhattarai lost in the 1958 and 1991 general elections, and was defeated again in the by-election held last february. however, highly placed nc sources said that bhattarai is seeking nomination to contest the november elections from constituency no.2 of syangja district in western nepal. according to the decision adopted by the july 27 meeting of nc central working committee (cwc), prime minister g.p. koirala, nc president bhattarai and the party's general secretary m.n. nidhi had "voluntarily offered to stay off the november elections" for the sake of keeping party unity. however, a later cwc meeting on september 14 decided "to leave it up to the leaders themselves to decide whether or not to contest the elections." it is yet to be known if koirala and nidhi would contest the polls.

------------------------------------------------------------------ SOURCE: Xinhua HEADLINE: nepali party nominates candidates for mid-term polls DATELINE: kathmandu, september 21; ITEM NO: 0921173
   the communist party of nepal (uml), the former main opposition, has nominated 196 candidates, including 12 women, to compete to the 205-seat lower house, according to uml sources today. the fresh mid-term polls is scheduled to be held in november which was declared by king birendra on july 11 on recommendation by prime minister g.p. koirala after his resignation on july 10. eight uml standing committee members, including party president man mohan adhikari, are among the candidates. adhikari will compete in two constituencies in kathmandu, no.1 and no.3 constituencies, simultaneously. madhav kumar nepal, uml general secretary and opposition leader in the upper house, will not take part in the polls. the list of candidates were prepared by a seven-member party committee and its leadership.

---------------------------------------------------------------------- SOURCE: Xinhua HEADLINE: indonesia defends decision to export ddt to nepal DATELINE: jakarta, september 22; ITEM NO: 0922173
   the indonesian government has defended its decision to unload some of its stock of ddt to nepal, saying that it was made at the request of the importing country. "we are exporting the ddt upon the request of the nepalese health minister," local press reports today quoted hadi m. abednego, director general of communicable disease control and environmental health at the ministry of health, as saying. he said that nepal needs dichloro-diphenyl-trichloroethane, popularly known as ddt, in its drive to eliminate malaria. nepal first showed its interest in importing ddt from indonesia during the annual south, east asian health ministerial meeting in katmandu in 1992, according to abednego, who pointed out that the ddt export has the endorsement of the world health organization (who), which is paying the transportation costs. indonesia, which outlawed the use of ddt in 1990, has been exporting ddt from its remaining stock to nepal and myanmar. last year, it shipped 200 tons of ddt to nepal and 100 tons to myanmar. the pesticide watch of nepal, a forum of local environmental journalists, recently sent a letter to the indonesian government pleading that the ddt export be discontinued because of the hazardous effects on the environment. the indonesia pesticide action network recently persuaded the government to destroy all the remaining ddt it still has in stock, instead of exporting it to foreign countries. on the other hand, the deputy director of who's office in jakarta, bambang winardi, defended who's decision to approve the import of ddt, saying that the possibilities of deaths caused by malaria were greater than the negative effects of ddt.

***************************************************************** Date: Sun, 25 Sep 1994 11:44 EST From: To:


[Excerpts from an article by Dr. Chunda Bajracharya in "Asmita", vol. 7, No. 26, July/august , 1994]

Language is increasingly a contested issue in multiparty Nepal. Nepali and Sanskrit is legitimated as a lingua franca, a medium of nationhood and natinal unity while others see this as but colonial artefact whose purpose is in line with the modernist project of homogenization and totalization and the suppression of other identities in the country.

In the forefront of this stuggle is the Nepal Bhasa or Newari language which was refused to die and be assimilated in this process of Nepalization. Even as early as the Licchavi period, the vernacular language of place names and rivers and mountains still are Newari in origin. Linguists take this as evidence of the deeply embedded nature and autochtonicity of Newari language at least in the Kathmandu valley.

Despite state suppression throughout much of the recorded history, Newari language has remained vibrant. Most of the credit has been given to male "men of letters" such as Chitta dhar Hridaya and Siddhi DAs. Dr Chunda Bajracharya who did her phd in nepal bhasa documents the contribution of Newari women in enriching Newari literature.

The earliest written record of Newari language is the inscription in the Hiranya Varna Mahavihar, Patan. This is dated 1115 A.D and gives the rules and regulations of the Buddhist monks. In 1175, we see a pharmacologia,
"Haramkhela" , the first textbook in newari.

During the reign of the Malla dynasty, Newari was a widely used language in vernacular and in the courts. several ballads, and poems were composed , capturing the dominant themes of the royal queens, namely power struggle, mututal hostility, devotion to their husbands and their family gods, envy and blame. There were 7 such female poetess.

The first is Hriddhi Laxmi of Kantipur, who composed, "Sowo, sowo,rasikan basant" ["look, look, at the charms of Spring"] was in the romanticist tradition, revelling in the joys and beauties of nature.

The second was Bhuvan Laxmi devi also of Kantipur, who composed poems that got the appreciation and patronage of the Malla queens. Her compositions include:
"Jaya devi, soguli bhuwanya rani" [Hail, oh lordess, queen of three domains!],
"Atisundar Desh Kantipur" [Oh how beautiful is our country Kantipur,{how she would suffer to see modern day kathmandu}], "Chi chamasiya ash" [Depending on you...] a religious votary.

Buddhi Laxmi of Bhaktapur composed,"Laghi ni mala",[Thou hast to care over me!] expressing her plea for kindness after being deprived of her rights at the whim of the royal decree. This must be a pretty patriarchical society .

Newari suffered systematic State withdrawal of patronage from Surendra bir Bikram Shah's period until in 1925 A.D.Dharmaditya Dharmacharya got inspired by the movement in Calcutta University that one should be educated in one's language. Dharmacharya came to Nepal to collect learning materials in Newari and began publishing "Buddha Dharm and nepal". this journal became an outlet for two other male writers who wrote under the female pennames of Prgjya and Tara. The goal was to encourage female participation in the rejuvenation of Newari literature. Articles such as "Maye lupin vidya janadi mala" or [women should start getting educated] was penned by Laxmi nani, a woman.

Then in 1938, Moti Laxmi Upasika , female Budhist monk, wrote a poem entitled,"How to write" inspiring other female writer to write by giving her own journey. She wrote prolifically in one of the first Nepali journals
"Sharada" and established her self in prose as well. Her topics wer about consciousness and subconsciousness. As recently as 1993, she published her collections of poems called ' "Chankhunchiya surbey" [A sparrow's wealth] Moti Laxmi was the sister of Chitadhar Hridaya, the doyen of Newari revival in modern times. Moti Laxmi expressed reverence and dedication to him and remained unmarried for life devoting herself to the ideals. Her themes touch the pains of living alone, imagining married life, rebellion against the Rana regime, Her writing is simple, clear and affective.

The next contribution was "Mukhuswan"[Bud] by Narayan devi Shrestha in 1955. Her themes emphasized female virtuosity and pride of feminity and motherhood and also revolt against inequity to women. She maintained that female power can shake the world, "Nariya pachina dharati chwiwan, bhu kampit jwi phaimakhu, chin jhigu pratap suryo gyai" or "If women so command, the earth will stop shaking and the sun will stop shining." from her poem "nari lai" [to women].

[the contributions of Newari women after 1955 will be dealt later.]

summarized, translated, and excerpted by Amulya tuladhar Clark university

[Editor, the following letter is reproduced by permission from Ajay Pradhan]

Subj: RE: Ganesh Man Quits Congress!

Ganesh Man Singh's move is calculated. He is a person who can live without the Congress party. This is manifested in his desire to be known and rmembered more as a statesman and national leader than as a politician.

If you consider Ganesh Man's persistent reluctance in accepting any position within the party and his unwillingness to stand an election and form a government, my hunch about his desire to rise from being a political leader to becoming a statesman appears logical.

The other important element that signals his desire is his willingness to forge ties the communists in times of crises that are of national significance. Although, at heart, he hates communists, his ability to rise above the partisan politics when occasions demand, simply puts him above other contemporary "leaders", within and outside of Nepali Congress. There is simply no one who can match up to him.

In 1989, if it was not for Ganesh Man, the coalition forces against the earstwhile partyless system would never have come into existence; and we would still continue to be under the Panchayat governance. There was no other leader who saw the need to be united with the communists to present a formidable force to the Panchayat system and to the palace.

Girija Prasad, for example, was never enthusiastic about rubbing shoulders with the communists even though he knew that a coalition was required to bring democracy. It was widely speculated that he was merely looking for an opportunity to enter the Panchayat system and try to become prime minister. This speculation, if it has even some hue of fact, would lead us to conclude that Girija Prasad was never more interested in democracy than he was in power. Going by Girija's more current action and theatrics, I have no reason to doubt that this speculation was not baseless.

The basic difference between Ganesh Man and Girija Prasad, therefore, is that Girija was always interested in power and was willing to get it at any cost whereas Ganesh Man always thought of preserving national interests and never ran after power of authority.

Amulya, this is not all there is to it, however. Ganesh Man, who has implicitly sought to be known as a national leader and a statesman, is after all someone who spent his life for Nepali Congress. Politics runs in his blood. He is too seasoned a politician to be so politically naive as to leave Congress party in a political lurch. He has spent too much time in this party to retire from the party. He has almost achieved some kind of "divine right" to be heard and followed, including by Girija Prasad.

However, Ganesh Man's feelings have been spurned by Girija too much and too often. In the past few weeks, Ganesh Man surely did not expect the Supreme Court to have ruled against Girija Prasad's move to recommend to King Birendra dissolution of parliament. Given the inherent flaws (and I think the extremist communists have been right all along on this issue) of Nepal's Constitution, Girija may very well have had the technical authority to do what he did.

I think this is where the irony lies. The main philosophy of the multiparty system of polity is that whoever in the majority party is elected or nominated the parliamentary party chief is invited by the King to form a government. When Girija lost crucial vote in the parliament, the simplest logic for the King should have been to imagine that the prime minister's parliamentary party leadership was not only being questioned but being challenged by his parliamentary party members. The King's action in accepting Girija's recommendation of dissolution of parliament is no better than King's acceptance of a similar recommendation by any other parliament member.

Amulya, your point that the interpretation of the Constitution by a Supreme Court headed by a person who himself was the chairman of the Constitution drafting committee is very relevant and important. The ethics in jurisprudence dictates that a court should interpret the *real intent* of the law or a Constitution, and not merely engage in technical interpretation. This is important, since a law or a Constitution is a living will of the lawmakers, rather than a lifeless bundle of documents with nothing but black and white letters.
  Now, since the Chief Justice himself was the chairman of the Constitution drafting committee, he knows best the *real intent* of costitutional provision. It is, therefore, sad that the Supreme Court has failed the Nepalese people in its interpretation of the Constitution.

It is small wonder, then, that Ganesh Man simply revolted against the outcome of the Supreme Court ruling by simply doing the best he could at this stage: Quitting Nepali Congress!

Now, no one is so politically naive to think that Ganesh Man will ever be out of Nepali Congress. He is doing this because he has no choice. If he stays on in the party, he has no option but to work for the party's victory in November elections. Party's victory in the upcoming election will be a jewel in Girija Prasad's political career-- something Ganesh Man is not inclined to give. If he continues to rmain in the party but remains passive in election campaigns he will be labeled as someone with petty personal polical interests without any true love for the party. Since his love for the party remains unfazed, the only way he could save the party from being a spent force in Nepal's politics is by staying out of it for the time being. Girija may have won battles, but has now lost the war.

Amulya, my analysis of the present political crisis in Nepal has become a little too long than I intended. Let me know what you think. The coming days will certainly be intersting to watch. By the way, I have, for the past few weeks, been unable to post any article on SCN due to some technical problem. If you think others on SCN might be interested to read this viewpoint, you are welcome to post this message on SCN.

Sincerely, Ajay

**************************************************************** Date: Mon, 26 Sep 94 17:26 EST From: Jain <> To: NEPAL NEPAL <> Subject: Looking for a Friend

Hi Everyone,

I am looking for an old friend - Rajesh Khanal. We studied together in New Delhi and then he did his college from Bangladesh. The last I knew was that he planned to come to the US for his masters. He resides in Kathmandu and his Dad was with Royal Nepal Airlines.

My email address is a bit long winded. It is:

Thanx Vineet

********************************************************************** Date: Sun, 25 Sep 94 14:16 EDT To: a10rjs1%NIU.BITNET@INTERBIT.UGA.EDU From: DGURUNG@CLEMSON.EDU Subject: nepal digest

Title: $10,500 toilet to grace Mount Everest Glasgow, Scotland (AP): The World's tallest moiuntain will soon be the site of the world's highest toilet. Associated Metal, a Scotish firm that normally makes sinks and commodes for hospitals, oil rigs and ships, has built a $10,500 state-of-the art outhouse that will be installed 20,000 feet up Mountain Everest.
"Until now, climbers and Sherpas have had to go off and find boulders and bushes to hide behind," said Phil Tolan, the company's managing director. "Now life will be a bit more comfortable, private and clean for them." Stell ropes anchored with ice picks are intended to keep the toilet and its occupants, from blowing over in howling Himalayan winds. It comes equipped with a wooden seat for warmth and a lock for privacy. The tiolet is being shipped to Nepal, where sherpas will carry it up the mountain in seven 50-pound sections that will be assembled for use by the 55-member British Mount Everest Medical Expedition. The group will conduct a research project on the mountain next month. Whent the scientist will finish their work, the tiolet will be dismantled and reassembled further down the slopes for use by visiting mountain climbers. Since Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay scalled Mount Everest's 29000 foot summit in 1953, hundreds of climbers attempting to follow in their ffotstemps have left behind tons of garbage and human wastes en route. The refuse decomposes slowly in the cold, rarefied environ ment. The Nepalese govt. has restricted the number of expeditions allowed and raised fees in an effort to protect the peak's fragile ecology. Note: This is an excerpt from local daily, "The News" from Greenville, SC, USA.

************************************************************************** From: To: Date: Wed, 28 Sep 94 01:25:40 EDT Subject: Resume:

Dear Friends,
        I am currently working on my M.B.A. and will soon be hunting for a job. I have been trying to put my resume and cover letter together and could use some help. I would appreciate it if somebody would send me a copy of their resume and cover letter (preferably a recent college graduate) or any other helpful comments.. Your help would be very much appreciated.

Thank You, Rajesh D. Acharya Address: RajeshA @

%% %%
%% %%

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue Jan 11 2000 - 11:15:31 CST